corpunWorld Corporal Punishment Research

ruler   :  Archive   :  2004   :  US Judicial May 2004



Judicial CP - May 2004

Corpun file 13355

logo (3WKYC-TV), Cleveland, Ohio, 5 May 2004

Fowler Police Chief suspended pending investigation into paddling accusations

FOWLER -- He's accused of paddling teenagers for traffic violations rather than giving them tickets.

James Martin

Now that northeast Ohio police chief has made a plea in court.

James Martin pleaded not guilty to a 52-count indictment.

At least two families have filed lawsuits against Martin saying that their sons were paddled by him.

Martin serves as the Fowler Township Police Chief and as a full time police captain in Howland Township.

He is on un-paid suspension from both jobs.

2003 WKYC-TV. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Corpun file 13324

The Times-Leader, Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, 5 May 2004

Police Chief Pleads Innocent in Paddling

Associated Press

WARREN, Ohio - A suburban police chief pleaded innocent Wednesday to a 52-count indictment alleging he paddled teen motorists for traffic violations.

Three teenagers have filed federal lawsuits alleging their privacy rights were violated when they were paddled as part of a diversion program run by Fowler Township Police Chief James Martin. One alleged he suffered welts in the videotaped, bare-bottom paddling.

Martin is charged with two felony counts of theft in office and misdemeanor counts of dereliction of duty, assault, unauthorized photography and using a sham legal process. The felony counts allege Martin stored police records in his home, and the sham legal process counts allege he showed juveniles a fake document that appeared to be official.

Martin's bond was set at $2,500, and a pretrial hearing was scheduled for Tuesday.

Martin, a part-time police chief who also is a full-time police captain in Howland, left court without commenting. He has been placed on unpaid suspension from both jobs.

Howland Township had disciplined Martin in 1993 after he admitted paddling about 20 juveniles in another diversion program. A child-services agency and a prosecutor who investigated separately said there was no evidence of abuse, but recommended the paddling stop.

Fowler and Howland townships are suburbs of Warren, located about 70 miles southeast of Cleveland.

2004 AP Wire and wire service sources. All Rights Reserved.

Corpun file 13409

The Vindicator, Youngstown, Ohio, 22 May 2004

Police chief discusses paddling, program

All of those paddled were fully clothed, an embattled police chief says

By Peggy Sinkovich
Vindicator Trumbull Staff

WARREN — Paddling was just a small portion of a juvenile diversion program in Fowler Township that is the subject of federal lawsuits and a grand jury indictment.

Speaking for the first time since being indicted earlier this month on 52 charges, Fowler Police Chief James Martin says the program was designed to keep teenagers on the right path.

"I care about kids," said Martin. "This program was not to hurt anyone, it was to help. I was available for those involved. They could talk to me."

He recalled one young man who told him "that when he was in junior high and got good grades, no one cared. When he was in high school and got bad grades, no one cared. He said I was the only one who cared. He is now going to graduate from college."

Martin would also insist that those involved in the program memorize a list of 17 rules, such as respecting others and staying out of trouble at home and at school.

"Corporal punishment was only one part of the program," Martin said. "A number of kids never got corporal punishment."

His reaction to probe

Martin, who will retire from his full-time position as captain at the Howland Township Police Department at month's end, said he is stunned by the investigation and indictments. He has pleaded innocent and is scheduled to return to court Tuesday.

"The fact that this would happen at the end of a 33-year career is a shock," Martin said. "I entered this profession because I wanted to help people. I thought I could help make a difference along the way."

The idea to start the juvenile diversion program came to Martin in the early 1970s after he investigated the suicide of a 16-year-old boy.

"I remember getting in my car and, after blowing my lunch, I kept asking myself, 'Why?'" Martin said. "Why? Why at 16 would this happen? What was missing? Who didn't pay attention?"

The diversion program in Howland began in the 1970s and lasted until 1993, when Martin was instructed to stop.

An investigation in 1993 by then-Howland Police Chief Steve Lamantia states that one juvenile complained at that time about being paddled as part of Martin's diversion program there. Martin told the chief at that time that he had the parents' permission to use corporal punishment. No charges were filed.

Program began again

In 1998, Martin became the Fowler Township's police chief. Sometime after assuming that post, he started a juvenile diversion program there. Martin said he was not sure of the exact date the program began in Fowler.

"I started it again because it worked," Martin said. He acknowledged that only a "handful" of juveniles took part in the Fowler program. He could not recall the number of juveniles who took part in the Howland program.

Not all those involved in the Fowler juvenile diversion program were referred by Martin. Other officers would stop teenagers on traffic or other misdemeanor charges and refer them to Martin "because they thought I could help," he said.

Several allegations by juveniles that they were paddled without their pants on are not true, said Martin and his attorney, Dominic Vitantonio of Cleveland.

"I'm very, very upset about that accusation and it is flat-out false," Martin said, adding that those paddled were always fully clothed.

The paddlings were also videotaped, Martin said.

"I made the videotapes so everybody would be protected and no one was paddled on bare bottoms," he stressed. "Also, no one was paddled in this program unless they and their parents agreed."

Martin also stressed that no one involved in the program was ever physically hurt.

One juvenile's claim

One of the juveniles involved in the program, however, stated in a civil lawsuit that he had welts after the paddling.

The FBI and agents from the state Bureau of Criminal Identification and Investigation are investigating Martin.

Free on a $2,500 bond, he faces 20 counts of dereliction of duty; 11 counts of misdemeanor assault; seven counts of unauthorized photography; 12 counts of using a sham legal process; and two felony counts of theft in office, said Dave Toepfer, an assistant Trumbull County prosecutor.

Authorities said the charge of sham legal process means Martin showed juveniles a document that appeared to be official but in reality had no legal standing and was not lawfully issued.

The theft charges stem from accusations he removed records from the Howland Township Police Department and took them home.

 2004 A service of The Vindicator.

blob Follow-up: 11 August 2004 - Ex-Chief Accused Of Paddling Teens Seeks To Settle

blob THE ARCHIVE index  Main menu page

Copyright Colin Farrell 2004
Page updated: September 2004